Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Student, in Business Administration, Rasht Branch, Islamic Azad University, Rasht, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration, Rasht Branch, Islamic Azad University, Rasht, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Today, the insurance industry plays a significant role in the prosperity of the economy, so paying attention to the creation of knowledge can play a significant role in increasing the penetration rate of insurance. Therefore, the main question of the current research is how to design and explain the model of the elements of customer knowledge co-creation in the insurance industry? In order to answer this question, the present research aims to identify the elements of the customer knowledge co-creation model in the insurance industry in the first stage, and in the next stage to test the relationship model of the elements of customer knowledge co-creation in the insurance industry, and based on the results of Data analysis will provide solutions to the managers of this industry in order to make decisions and policies related to knowledge creation and as a result promote and improve insurance products and services and increase the penetration rate of insurance in the society.

Literature Review
 Knowledge Co-Creation
Knowledge Co-Creation has been described as an act of collective creativity, with applications ranging from product and service design to more abstract spheres of value creation taking place between two or more individuals who may or may not belong to the same actor group (Amann & Rubinelli, 2017). “Customer knowledge Co-creation is defined as the collective ability of group members to analyze, interpret, reconfigure customer-related knowledge, and it means that knowledge is co-created by group members” (Menguc et al., 2013). In the following, we discuss some of the researches conducted in the field of customer knowledge co-creation.
Itani et al. (2022) conducted a study with the aim of investigating the effects of using social media and customer relationship management technology on the customer knowledge co-creation and sales performance in B2B companies. Based on the theories of task-technology fit and self-determination, the findings show that social media, customer relationship management technology, and their interaction, support salespeople in joint value-creation efforts through the mediating role of knowledge enriched by these tools. The results indicated a significant moderating effect of the salesperson's job independence and the ease of the sales quota in increasing the relationship between knowledge and value co-creation.
Xie et al. (2020), in a study titled "Using Customer Knowledge for Service Innovation in Travel Agency Industry", investigated the influencing factors and the effects of service team access and the combination of customer knowledge on tourist service companies. The results showed that both factors of customer orientation and intensity of interaction are effective on customer knowledge co-creation teams, which can promote service innovation. Also, the results indicated that customer knowledge co-creation moderates the relationship between interaction intensity and service innovation.

Methodology
The current research was done in two stages using a mixed method. In this research, in order to identify the components of the customer knowledge co-creation model, first the qualitative approach of grounded theory was used. For this purpose, semi-structured interviews were conducted with a selection of insurance industry experts, including a number of university professors and insurance company managers, as a result of which the components of the research and their dimensions were identified. Then, in order to present the relationship model of the main components of the research, the opinions of experts were evaluated through the matrix of pairwise comparisons, and based on this, the conceptual model of the research was explained. Then, in order to test the research model and hypotheses, the partial least squares quantitative method was used. The statistical population in the quantitative stage consists of managers and experts of three active insurance companies in Iran, including Alborz, Iran, and Asia. The statistical sample was obtained from the random cluster sampling method, based on which 310 people were selected as a statistical sample. The data collection tool in the quantitative stage is a researcher-made questionnaire. Cronbach's alpha method was used to check the reliability of the measurement tool, and its value was greater than 0.7 for all variables. Therefore, all variables were confirmed in terms of reliability.

Results
In the first stage of the current research, the qualitative method of grounded theory was used to identify the components and dimensions of customer knowledge co-creation. As a result of this stage, 7 main aspects were identified for customer knowledge co-creation. After identifying the research components and developing the model, 9 hypotheses were formulated in the quantitative stage. Based on the findings of data analysis using the partial least squares method, all 9 research hypotheses were confirmed. The results showed that the infrastructure of information and communication technology has an effect on being knowledge-oriented. Also, being knowledge-oriented has an impact on internal marketing and customer relationship management. In addition, the effect of internal marketing and customer relationship management on customer orientation was confirmed. Also, the effect of customer orientation on creating motivation and trust building was confirmed, and finally, the effect of creating motivation and trust building on customer knowledge co-creation was confirmed.

Discussion
Customer knowledge co-creation is a process by which organizations acquire competencies and knowledge of customers, so that they can use this information to create an experience for customers and reach new markets for themselves.

Conclusion
According to the confirmation of all 9 research hypotheses and with emphasis on the structures (sub-indices) that have the highest factor load obtained from the partial least squares method, the following practical suggestions are presented:
In order to develop the component of “information and communication technology infrastructures” in insurance companies, considering the importance of "the company's presence in social media and producing up-to-date content", it is suggested that managers of insurance companies use experts who have enough expertise in the field of content production to manage social media pages. Also, through social pages, they can establish a two-way relationship with customers, especially special customers, and encourage them to share their insurance knowledge and experiences.
In line with the development of “internal marketing”, the managers of insurance companies should continuously strive to hold brainstorming sessions with the employees in order to update their knowledge and skills. In these meetings, in addition to presenting technical matters such as informing about possible changes in insurance policies, new insurance laws, etc., experts in fields such as marketing, psychology, and negotiation can also be invited so that the employees and the sales network, in addition to mastering the technical skills, also master the communication skills of the day.
In order to ensure customer satisfaction and as a result of complying with customer-oriented principles, insurance companies must first observe and understand the needs of their customers. For this purpose, they should listen to the expectations and criticisms of the customers, and by establishing a friendly relationship with them, in addition to getting to know the customers more and knowing their level of satisfaction, they should have a positive effect on their perception.
In order to increase the “trust of customers”, insurance companies should adopt strategies that lead to improving the mental image of customers towards the company's brand. Since the main mission of insurance companies is to issue perfect insurance policies as well as timely and adequate payment of damages, if this is done correctly, it can play an effective role in attracting customers’ trust.
Finally, in order to develop the customers' knowledge co-creation, insurance companies should use the experiences and knowledge gained from customers to produce and create new knowledge and improve and develop the organization's products and services.

Keywords

Main Subjects

 
Abbate, T, Codini, A & Aquilani, B. (2019). Knowledge Co- creation in Open Innovation Digital Platforms: Processes, Tools and services, Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, 0885-8624. http://doi.org/ 10.1108/JBIM-09-2018-0276
Amann, J & Rubinelli, S. (2017). Views of Community Managers on Knowledge Co-Creation in Online Communities for People with Disabilities: Qualitative Study, Journal of medical Internet research, 19(10), 1-16. https://doi.org/ 10.2196/jmir.7406
Archarya, A., Singh, S. K., Pereira, V & Singh, P. (2018). Big Data, Knowledge Co-Creation and Decision Making In Fashion Industry, International Journal of Information Management, 42, 90-101.
Beaudon, G & Soulier, E. (2019, February). Customer Experience Analytics in Insurance: Trajectory, Service Interaction and Contextual Data, [International Conference on Information Technology & Systems], Springer, Cham. 187-198.
Chami, A & Kaddeche, S. (2021). The effect of internal marketing on knowledge sharing: a case study of Algerian National Bank BNA, The International Journal in Economics and Business Strategies, 5(3), 966-979.
Cheng, B. (2015). Effect of Customer Relationship Managementon Employees'customer Orientation, [Ph.D Disseration]. University of Rhode Island, United States, Kingstone.
Cheung, M. F & To, M.W. (2012). How Does Customer Motivational Orientation Affect Satisfaction?, Journal of Financial Services, Marketing, 17(2), 135-147.
De Silva, M., Al- Tabbaa, O & Pinto, J. (2023). Academic Engaging In Knowledge Transfer And Co- Creation: Push Causation and Pull Effectuation?, Research Policy, (52), 1-15.
Fischer, L & Maas, P. (2019). Beyond Competition–How Cooperation Fosters Customer Experience in Service Industries. In Kooperative Dienstleistungen, Springer Gabler, Wiesbaden, 477-504
Goyal, S., Ahuja, M & Kankanhalli, A. (2020). Does The Source of External Knowledge Matter? Examining the Role of Customer Co-Creation and Partner Sourcing in Knowledge Creation and Innovation, Information & management, 57(3).
Guan, X-H., Xie, L & Huan, T. (2018). Customer Knowledge Sharing, Creativity and Value Co- Creation: A Trial Model of Hotels, Corporate Sales, Employees and Their Customers, International journal of contemporary hospitality management, 30(2), 961-979.
Ind, N & Coats, N. (2013). The Meaning of Co-Creation, European Business Review, 25(1), 86-95. https://doi.org/101108/09555341311287754.
Itani, O.S., Calra, A & Riley, J. (2022). Complementary Effects of CRM and Social Media on Customer Co-Creation and Sales Performance in B2B Firms: The Role of Salesperson Self-Determination Needs, Information & Management, 59(3).
James, G., Witten, Da., Hastie, T & Tibshirani, R. (2017). An Introduction to Statistical Learning, (8th Ed.), Springer Science+Business Media, New York
Kandampully, J., Zhang, T & Jaakkola, E. (2018). Customer Experience Management in Hospitality: A Literature Synthesis, New Understanding and Research Agenda, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 30(1), 21-56.
Liao, S.H., Chen, Y.J & Deng, M.Y. (2010). Mining Customer Knowledge for Tourism New Product Development and Customerrelationship Management, Expert Systems with Applications, 37(6), 4212-4223.
Lou, J., Fang, Y., Kai, H. L & Peng, J. Z. (2013). Contributing High Quantity and Quality Knowledge to Online Q&A Communities, Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 64(2), 356–371.
Menguc, B. (2013). To Be Engaged or Not to Be Engaged: The Antecedents and Consequences of Service Employee Engagement, Journal of business research, 6(11), 2163-2170
Misransyah, Risal, S., Khariry, M., Asmawatiy, C & Welly Saputra, R. (2023). Building Trust Through Quality of Service Mediated With Satisfaction to Acceptors of Family Planning in The Province of South Kalimantan, Heliyon, (9), 1-13.
Muliro, J. (2017). Assessment of The Key Success Factors of Strategic Knowledge Management That Influence Organizational Performance: A Case of the World Agroforestry Centre [Doctoral dissertation]. United States International University-Africa.
Nwora, N.G &Uzoamaka, O.E. (2017). Effects of Internal Marketing on Customer Orientation Behaviour of Selected Hotels' Employee's in Nigeria, European Scientific Journal. 13(19). 212-232. https://doi.org/10.19044/esj.2017.v13n16p212
OkaWindarti, G.A., Alhadi, E., Zahara, E & Andriani, T. (2020). Impact of Customer Orientation and Quality of Ervice on Trust and Customer Loyalty, Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Researchm (3rd forum in Research, Science and Technology).
Ometto Bezzarra, M, Vollmer, D., Souter, N.J & Shaad, K; Hauck, S; Clara Marques, M. (2023). Stakeholder Engagement and Knowledge Co- Production for Better Watershed Management with the Fresh Water Health Index, Curent research in invironmental sustainability, (5), 1-15.
Pan, S. L., Newell, S, Huang, J & Galliers, R. D. (2007). Overcoming Knowledge Management Challenges during ERP Implementation: The Need to Integrate and Share Different Types of Knowledge, Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 58(3). 404-419.
Randall, W.S., Gravier, M. J, Prybutok, V.R. (2011). Connection, trust and commitment: Dimensions of Co- creation?, Marketing Department Journal Articles, (27).
Roy, S. K., Singh, G., Hatton, C & Dey, B. (2022). Customer's Motives to Co-Create In Smart Services Interactions, Electronic Commerce Research. 3(5).
Ruhanen, L., Saito, N & Axelsen, M. (2021). Knowledge co-creation: The role of Tourism Consultants, Annals of Tourism Research, 87, 1-11.
Storey, C & Larbig, C. (2018). Absorbing Customer Knowledge: How Customer Involvement Enables Service Design Success, Journal of Service Research, 21(1), 101-118.
Voorberg, W.H., Bekkers, V.J., J.M & Tummers, L. G. (2015). A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production: Embarking On the Social Innovation Journey, Public Management Review, 17(9), 1333–1357. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2014.930505
Wang, Y., Zhang, R., Wu, J & Li, Ch. (2019). The Construction of 'User Knowledge Product' Co- Creation Knowledge Cyberspace Served for Product Innovation, [11th CIRP Conference on Industrial Product-Service Systems] (Sience Direct), 467-472
Witell, L., Kowalkowski, C., Perks, H., Raddats, C., Schwabe, M., Benedettini, O & Burton, J. (2019). Characterizing Customer Experience Management in Business Markets, Journal of Business Research. 2 (15), 14-28
Xie, L, Guan, X, Cheng, Q & Huan, T.C. (2020). Using Customer Knowledge for Service Innovation in Travel Agency Industry, Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 45, 113-123.
Yaghoobi, N.M., Khaksar, M.S., Banihashemi, A & Afshar Jahanshahi, A. (2011). The Impact of Knowledge Management on Customer Relationship Management, European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences, 34, 76-85.
Zhang, Y., Zhang, M., Luo, N., Wang, Y & Niu, T. (2019). Understanding the Formation Mechanism of High-Quality Knowledge in Social Question and Answer Communities: A Knowledge Co-Creation Perspective, International Journal of Information Management, 2(48), 72-8.
References [in Persian]
Ahmadi, Farid, Tari, Hojat & Ahmadi, Soheila. (2017). Presenting a model for customer knowledge management in Post Bank of Iran, Commercial Surveys Bimonthly, 17(96), 78-92. [in Persian]
Ahmadi. F, Tari, H & Ahmadi, S. (2018). Presenting a Model for Customer Knowledge Management in Iran Post Bank, Bimonthly Journal of Business Studies, 17(96), 78-92. [in Persian]
Ehsanfar, G & Garoosi, E. (2017). The Effect of Customer Knowledge on Organizational Performance according To the Role of Customer Relationship Management and Marketing Capabilities in Insurance Companies, Insurance research paper. 4(21). 49-72. [in Persian]
Ehsanfar, Golshan & Garousi, Elnaz. (2015). The effect of customer knowledge on organizational performance according to the role of customer relationship management and marketing capability in insurance companies, Insurance Research Journal, 4(21), 49-72. [in Persian]
Ghafari, S & Zeiali, M. A. (2018). Investigating the Information Technology Infrastructure for Implementing Knowledge Management in the Visual Archive (Qom Audio and Video Center), Journal of Information Management Sciences and Techniques, 2(4), 111-136. [in Persian]
Ghaffari, Saeed & Zeinali, Mohammad Ali. (2016). Review of information technology infrastructure for the implementation of knowledge management in the visual archive (audio and television center of Qom), Quarterly Journal of Information Management Sciences and Techniques, 2(4), 111-136. [in Persian]
Habibi, A & Kolahi, B. (2022). Structural Equation Modeling and Factor Analysis. Tehran: Jihad Academic Press. [in Persian]
Habibi, Arash & Kolahi, Bahareh. (2022). Structural equation modeling and factor analysis, second edition, Tehran: Jihad Academic Publications. [in Persian]
Hakimi, H, Diwandari, A, Kimasi, M & Haghighi, Mehdi (2020). Providing a Model for Shaping the Experience of Micro-Banking Customers through Agents under the Management of the Organization with an Interpretive Structural Modeling Approach, Business Management Quarterly, 11, (3), 565-584. [in Persian]
Hakimi, Hajar, Divandari, Ali, Keimasi, Masoud & Haghighi, Mehdi. (2018). Presenting the formation model of retail banking customers' experience through the factors under the management of the organization with the interpretive structural modeling approach, Business Management Quarterly, 11(3), 584-565. [in Persian]
Hamidizadeh, M. R & Kheirkhah Askarabad, M. R. (2013). Investigating the Effect of Marketing Knowledge Management Capabilities on Organizational Performance in the Iranian Petrochemical Industry, Quarterly Scientific Research Journal of Business Management Explorations, 4(8), 30-45. [in Persian]
Hamidizadeh, Mohammadreza & Kheirkhah Askarabad, Mohammadreza (2011). Investigation of the effect of marketing knowledge management capabilities on the performance of the organization in the petrochemical industry of Iran, Scientific Research Quarterly of Business Management Explorations, 4(8), 30-45. [in Persian]
Hoseinee nia, S. R, Bay, N & Ghanbarpoor, A. (2020). The Role of Customer Relationship Management on the Level of Customer Orientation of Employees of Sports and Youth Departments in Golestan Province, Journal of Human Resource Management in Sports, 2(7), 207-223. [in Persian]
Hosseini, Seyed Reza, Bai, Nasser & Qanbarpour, Amir (2019). The role of customer relationship management on the level of customer orientation of employees of sports and youth departments in Golestan province, Journal of Human Resource Management in Sports, 2(7), 207-223. [in Persian]
Sarla, M, Danaee, H. & Khalatbari, M. (2016). The role of internal marketing in facilitating knowledge management practices, Human Resources Studies Quarterly, 3(12), 29-50. [in Persian]
Sarlak, Mohammad Ali, Danaei, Habibollah & Khal’atbari, Maryam (2013) The role of internal marketing in facilitating knowledge management practices, Human Resource Studies Quarterly, 3(12), 29-50. [in Persian]
Shahsavani, M, Rezaee Dolatabadi, H. & Ranjbaran, B. (2016). The Effect of Internal Marketing and Customer Orientation, a Case Study in the Municipalities of Shiraz and Neiriz, Modern Urban Management Quarterly, 2(7), 155-176. [in Persian]
Shahsavani, Massoud, Rezaei Dolat-Abadi, Hossein & Ranjbaran, Bahram. (2013). Effect of internal marketing and customer orientation of a case study in the municipality of Shiraz and Niriz, Modern Urban Management Quarterly, (7), 155-176. [in Persian]